《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹 ---- 作者:倍魄

韩寒曾经有两个亲密战友,李承鹏和路金波。在李承鹏发微博声明“选择单玩”之前,路金波不仅安排了土豆网的调查和采访,还亲自对着摄像镜头宣告:“说韩寒‘懒,不学无术’,这些我都承认……”。我们一下子不知道路老板到底是在保韩还是在卖韩了。同样,决定出版《光明与磊落》的路总,你是要给韩寒提供证明呢?还是给质疑派提供证据呢?当然,对于书商来说,卖书就是卖人,当韩寒找到了金丽华打理商务,路老板大概是要抓住最后一次出卖韩寒的机会吧?钱,才是硬道理。

  那么,《磊落》的手稿到底是能提供清白,还是说只是奉献了证供呢?至少,我们发现在“磊落”的虚表下面,他们还是想掩盖什么,并且从中我们可以发现不可告人的秘密。
(一)并不磊落的掩盖:
  在209页、213页他们特别用浓墨涂黑了手稿,在270页他们裁掉了手稿的底部。一篇手稿,会有什么不可告人的秘密必须如此掩盖?以至于连稿页都沾上了墨印的指纹?磊落的意思就是涂黑和裁切吗?自证的诚意在哪里?

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹
《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹
《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

(二)十分神秘的失踪:
  “小心保存了13年”的手稿,有三页居然搞丢了!“缺失”不是唯一的困难,还必须“破着头发”解释那些消失的字是被出版社“爱国主义删节”了。哦,依你这么说,前面的那些涂黑和裁掉,可以说成是“爱作主义删节”喽?可是,192-202页共11页手稿也不见踪影,韩方作何解释?你还有多少秘密?

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

(三)可从165页开始的稿纸就突然变脸了:

  P3-P163,P192-P422都是用的同一种稿纸,包括P403-P422声称的“《三重门》未采用手稿片段”,稿纸样子如下:

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹
《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

  165页至184页稿纸的底部样式:

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹
《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

185页至191页稿纸的底部样式:

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

(四)不仅是变脸,而且是变老:
  从164页到191页,不仅是神秘“丢失”了14页文稿,而且在这里换了两种稿纸;不仅仅是稿纸变脸,而且是稿纸变老。非P164-191的稿纸印刷规范,纸张很新的样子:

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

  而P164-191的两种稿纸却又破又旧:

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

  可以断言,162页到202页手稿,不仅“丢失”了14页,而且,展示出来的部分,其书写时间也比较早。而所谓“丢失”,不过是另一种意义上的涂黑和裁掉。

(五)不仅稿纸变脸,字体也变老:
  165页到184页文稿的字迹,尽管与其它页文稿的字迹相似,但绝对不是同一人所写,即使不是笔迹专家,也能看出其间的差别。除了一些常用字的写法很不一样,更主要的区别是繁体字在165页到184页频繁出现。(185-191页虽换了稿纸,但字迹与165页到184页文稿的不同,而与文稿大部分字迹一致。)
  【推论】165页到184页文稿的字迹为另一人所写,其余的文稿字迹为韩寒所写。185页至191页的字迹,为韩寒在旧稿纸上书写,并模仿165页到184页文稿的字迹,为的是使整个文稿的外貌有一个自然一些的过渡。在书写时间上,165页到184页最早,可能为韩仁均书写。
  在162、163、164三页神秘“丢失”之后,手稿突然变脸,突然出现了很多繁体字写法,我对165页和166页的繁体字迹进行全书查找统计发现:156页和166页,两页文稿共748字,其中出现繁体字写法除了一个“长”共10个字,出现几率为1.34%。《三重门》手稿刨除162页到184页,字数达148000余字,却找不到这些字的繁体写法(除了全书偶尔有“车”和“长”的繁体写法)。按几率计算,148000余字应当有1979个上述10字的繁体写法出现,但事实上,这10个字的繁体写法却再也没有出现!
  以其中5字为例,它们出现的页码(色为繁体出现)全部如下:
:87 164 165
:47 60 61 88(4) 93(3) 95 139 165 202 310 340 365 370 371
:11 85 90 123 127 166 185 197 199 212 273 295 299 311 318 348 374
:16 25 32 103 111 128 132 154 155 159 160 166 167 186 200 226(2)
    250 264 273 276 297 309 311(2) 324 352 360
:165(2) 166 174 205(2) 214 257 370 215(库)

  除了繁体证据,还有重要的证据是常用字“是”的写法。在165页-184页前半页之间,共7560字,“是”字用了103次,100次用了“  ”的写法,只在抄写高晓松的《青春无悔》歌词时,用了3次“  ”的写法。在165页-184页之外,“  ”的写法完全不见了!
  一个人的写字习惯是可以随着岁月有所改变的,但对于“天才之靠”的一气呵成的快速成书而言,在写到165页突然改变习惯(写繁体字,改变常用字写法),又在改变了19页半之后,这些改变又突然消失。这对于同一个书写者,尤其是专心文学创作,而不是演练硬笔书法的人来说,是不可思议的。唯一的合理解释就是,这些字是韩寒之外的另一个人所写,而其它字是韩寒抄写!而且,这一点有两个辅助证据:
  一、162、163、164三页手稿神秘“丢失”,恰好丢在变脸之前;
  二、165页至184页用同一种稿纸,同时又与其它页稿纸完全不同!也就是说,变稿纸与变字迹又恰好同时发生。

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

《三重门》手稿并非韩寒一人笔迹

为了回应方舟子的质疑,韩寒匆忙拿出来“原创手稿”来证明《三重门》是他所写。可惜,这个“原创手稿”居然不是同一个人的笔迹!韩寒,你太弱了!路金波,你太坏了!

(倍魄 2012/6/6)

来源:http://blog.sina.com.cn/s/blog_53ece6da0100zxo5.html

分类: 

参与评分: 

还没有评价

评论

访客的头像

路金波对韩一和韩二说:反正已经提供了很多证据了,也不差再提供一次。但这是我们最后一次消费韩二的机会了,能挣点就挣点吧。然后就【磊落】了。

访客的头像

又有新证据了,感谢笔者的辛劳!有关质疑韩骗的抄写、代笔的证据已经好多了,现在重要的是要成为法律上的铁证。影响如此之深如此广泛的作假牟利为什么得不到法律的严惩呢?真的不明白!!!

访客的头像

纸是包不住火的!!
韩骗经营十几年,最后已经相信自己就是天才,能够所向披靡!!
但在真正的高手面前,韩骗又是如此的漏洞百出,不堪一击!!
邪不胜正------应了这句名言!!
向倍魄高手致敬!!

访客的头像

如山铁证面前,韩家父子怎么还能死挺不倒啊!非得气死所有诚信中国人吗?

Hermes belt Nike Roshe Runs

There are several things to

James Kessler的头像

There are several things to consider if you purchase Dansko shoes or some Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream other producers associated with shoes. Does the style and design fit ordinary clothing collection? Would you like reasonable and enjoyable to Yeezy Boost 350 v2 cream utilize whilst going for a walk a fairly short distance? How frequently contemplating by using this shoes?How lengthy will be the life? Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 black Are definitely the products applied both equally difficult and chic? Will be the shop price worth the money? A lot of men and women want to invest in Yeezy Boost 350 v2 black genuinely expensive, uncomplicated, and sturdy couples picturing over-use along with limited maintenance will not wear them out. They just do not Yeezy Boost 550 look at the life expectancy regarding shoe Adidas Yeezy 750 Boost furthermore be determined by just how you adopt good these. Will not dismiss your individual shoes for the reason that you got all of them with adjusted price. Dansko shoe Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 kids along with designers will last which you life-time should you maintain and keep these people properly. Shoe Care Tips- Do not wait for a high heels connected Yeezy Boost with shoes into the Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 future off before these phones any cobbler regarding repair service. When your individual women's high heel sandals present early signs and symptoms of injury, get them to the particular repair center http://www.yeezyboost350v2zebras.com/ and have absolutely these individuals repaired right away.- Prevent donning precisely the same match two times uninterruptedly. Rotate your own discounted Dansko shoes with your very own other Yeezy Boost 950 pairs. This will likely keep your individual shoe Yeezy 350 v2 last much more time and also wear significantly less. Recurrent utilize raise outside and inside damage.- Buckskin shoes are near likelihood of Yeezy 750 Boost getting dehydrated. This leads to these to drop the sparkle. Frequently gloss leather shoes to make sure they're damp and shiny. Fortunately, almost all home improvement stores in addition to hassle-free stores hold Adidas Yeezy Boost synthetic leather shoe develop you can get.- When possible, put on hosiery with all sorts of shoes, especially sealed kinds. Sweating can harm Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white the interior of your family shoes. Maintaining your particular toes surrounded within shoes Adidas Yeezy Boost without having natural cotton to soak up the particular sweat additionally causes unfavorable ft . situations like unique odor. - Discount Dansko shoes or some other designers created from Yeezy Boost 350 v2 canvas could be cleansed the appliance as well as manually. Fill the particular insides together with paper to maintain their condition. Confirm the container should Yeezy Boost 750 they have got unique cleansing directions.- Have a gentle bristled brush Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 zebra convenient. Watertight suede only need to possess the grime carefully covered out. Much more extreme cleanup just like keeping them soaked may well destruction the suede end.If lowering costs along with http://www.yeezyboost750shoes950.com/ preserving sets looking brand new will not be ample Adidas Yeezy Boost 750 payment to adopt much better good care of shoe, recall well cared shoe strengthen your personal legs, also. Terribly managed shoes include the origins involving poor foot complications such as Adidas Yeezy Boost 950 fungus infections and sores. If you decide on Dansko shoes and other makers, consider the convenience Yeezy Boost 350 v2 kids your very own foot. Select the right dimension and also fit for proper ventilation. Taking proper your own personal shoes have become basic and incredibly gratifying. You'll be conserving us dollars Adidas Yeezy 350 Boost via continuous shoe corrects and acquiring brand new ones. If you buy Dansko shoes or any Adidas Yeezy Boost 550 other variations as well as product labels, verify how they incorporate additional care in addition to washing information. It isn't enough to invest your very own whole finances upon Adidas Yeezy Boost 350 v2 white expensive shoe along with suppose them to always be definitely worth Yeezy 350 Boost the expense. Do not forget the life span of your personal shoe depends on how good you adopt proper these.

Nike Lebron 15 Adidas Yeezy

Timberland Boots For Women

mont blanc

访客的头像

mont blanc

ray ban wayfarer

tory burch outlet online

coach outlet store online

coach factory outlet

polo ralph lauren sale

michael kors outlet clearance

polo ralph lauren

valentino outlet

uggs outlet

polo shirts

coach factory outlet

fitflops shoes

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap jordans for sale

polo ralph lauren outlet

asics shoes

canada goose outlet online

ralph lauren shirts

canada goose jackets

kate spade outlet

canada goose outlet store

canada goose outlet

michael kors outlet

ugg outlet

uggs on sale

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

cheap oakley sunglasses

mont blanc outlet

christian louboutin sale

nike outlet

longchamp outlet

michael kors outlet online

canada goose jackets

cheap authentic nba jerseys

canada goose

polo ralph lauren outlet online

michael kors outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

pandora charms

mbt

valentino outlet

coach outlet

pandora outlet store

coach outlet store online

longchamp outlet

true religion jeans sale

ugg outlet

kate spade handbags

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

canada goose jackets

tory burch outlet

ugg boots

coach factory outlet

canada goose outlet online

polo ralph lauren

moncler outlet

ralph lauren uk

tory burch outlet

polo ralph lauren

ray bans

polo ralph lauren outlet

polo ralph lauren

canada goose outlet

ugg boots clearance

ugg outlet

oakley sunglasses

michael kors outlet

christian louboutin outlet

polo outlet

pandora outlet

uggs outlet

jordan retro

michael kors outlet

adidas shoes for men

michael kors outlet online

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet online

jordan shoes

nike outlet

ugg boots

polo ralph lauren

coach outlet store online

pandora jewelry

ugg outlet

ferragamo shoes sale

nike shoes

coach factory outlet

michael kors outlet online

cheap uggs

pandora charms

ralph lauren outlet

canada goose outlet

ugg boots

michael kors outlet

canada goose jackets

pandora outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

coach factory outlet

ugg outlet

polo outlet

ugg boots clearance

hermes birkin

kate spade handbags

ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren outlet

giuseppe zanotti outlet

michael kors outlet

longchamp outlet

michael kors outlet clearance

michael kors handbags

air max 2017

uggs outlet

canada goose outlet

ed hardy clothing

michael kors outlet clearance

ralph lauren polo

fred perry clothing

uggs canada

oakley sunglasses outlet

lacoste shirts

ugg boots clearance

coach outlet

coach outlet online

canada goose jackets

adidas yeezy shoes

ugg boots

coach outlet online

pandora bracelet

polo ralph lauren outlet online

ugg outlet

coach outlet online

uggs canada

michael kors outlet

ray ban wayfarer

uggs outlet

ray ban outlet

polo ralph lauren outlet

ralph lauren

ed hardy

yeezy boost

ugg outlet store

canada goose

canada goose jackets

cheap oakley sunglasses

lacoste clothing

canada goose outlet store

michael kors outlet online

polo ralph lauren outlet

michael kors outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet store

christian louboutin outlet

ray ban sunglasses outlet

michael kors outlet

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

canada goose outlet online

canada goose

canada goose outlet

coach outlet online

nike shoes for men

ferragamo shoes

coach outlet store online

michael kors outlet online

coach outlet

michael kors outlet

cheap ugg boots

ugg outlet store

cheap oakley sunglasses

ray-ban sunglasses

ugg outlet

cheap oakley sunglasses

kate spade outlet store

ugg boots clearance

canada goose outlet

nmd adidas

moncler outlet

canada goose jackets

uggs outlet

cheap jordans for sale

uggs outlet

oakley sunglasses wholesale

mont blanc pens

canada goose outlet

canada goose jackets

coach factory outlet

coach outlet store online

cheap nfl jerseys

ray ban sunglasse

fitflops outlet

ugg outlet

adidas outlet online

canada goose jackets

ralph lauren pas cher

canada goose outlet

polo ralph lauren

cheap jerseys wholesale

mont blanc pens

yaoxuemei20171221

Ralph Lauren Outlet Longchamp

页面

添加新评论

简单文本编辑

  • 自动将网址与电子邮件地址转变为链接。
  • 自动断行和分段。